Recent Cases | Smith Bowyer Clarke

Expert team of Barristers and Solicitors with years of experience in providing advice and representation in Road Transport Law.

Please find some of our recent cases below.

Filter by Category


Bus Operator Escapes Maximum Financial Penalty for Non Compliance at Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - June 2025

Efforts to improve compliance, investment in roller brake equipment and more administrative support to monitor bus timetable compliance were part of the evidence that Murray Oliver used to help this Bus operator at Public Inquiry. A robust challenge was made to the DVSA evidence on Bus Timetable compliance which helped […]

Civil Penalty for Clandestine Entrants Reduced by £8,208 - June 2025

A timely Notice of Objection lodged by Murray Oliver on behalf of a Lithuanian Operator with a single clandestine entrant found in its trailer successfully reduced the penalty imposed by Border Force by £8,208.

Clandestine Entrants Civil Penalty Reduced by 83% - June 2025

Murray Oliver lodged a Notice of Objection on behalf of a Romanian Haulier who was facing an £80,000 penalty after 5 Immigrants were discovered in one of its vehicles. The Overall Penalty for Both Owner Hirer and Driver was reduced by 83.3%

Traffic Commissioner Cuts Starting Point in Half for Mobile Phone Conviction at Driver Conduct Hearing - May 2025

This driver, represented at his driver conduct hearing by barrister Harry Bowyer, looked at his phone when a text came in. He had an exemplary driving record and was dealing with his terminally ill mother at the time and was expecting bad news. The Traffic Commissioner accepted that this was […]

Approved Driving Instructor with Caution for Assault Remains on the Register - May 2025

Laura Newton represented an Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) who had reported a caution for assault to the Registrar and was facing removal from the Register of Approved Driving Instructors. We were able to prepare written representation to the Registrar, outlining the previous good conduct, present the facts and the mitigation […]

£27,000 Clandestine Entrant Penalty Reduced by 88% After Notice of Objection - May 2025

When 3 clandestine entrants were found inth back of our client’s trailer at Calais a £27,000 civil penalty was issued. The fine could have started at £60,000 but the operator secured some reductions because he was compliant with the regs. Murray Oliver drafted a Notice of objection which secures secured […]

Card Pulling HGV Driver Avoids Sentence in the Crown Court - April 2025

Our client, a HGV Driver, was prosecuted by DVSA following an investigation at his place of work into Tachograph and Drivers’ Hours compliance. He was charged with 5 offences of creating a false tachograph record and an offence of failure to make a record. The prosecutor indicated that their submission […]

Director with Serious Criminal Conviction Keeps Good Repute at Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - April 2025

Laura Newton represented a Company at Public Inquiry before the Traffic Commissioner. The sole director of the Company, who was also the nominated Transport Manager had been convicted of a serious offence, for which a suspended sentence of 8 months had been imposed. This called into question the repute and […]

Clandestine Entry penalty reduced by £78,000 following Appeal to County Court - April 2025

Murray Oliver was asked to deal with a case where following the discovery of 10 clandestine entrants in a trailer at Dunkirk UK Border Force imposed £120,000 civil penalty on the Operator and its driver. The operator’s first attempt at lodging a notice of objection failed to secure any reduction […]

Operator Escapes with Formal Warning at Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry After Card Pulling Driver Found by DVSA - April 2025

When this restricted operator, represented by senior solicitor Murray Oliver was informed that one of their drivers had been creating false tachograph records a Public Inquiry was guaranteed. We advised the operator through all the stages of the investigation and the Traffic Commissioner concluded that the efforts to improve all […]

Ask a Question

Let us know how we can help. Just provide a brief outline of your query.







    Free Consultation Motoring Law