Recent Cases | Smith Bowyer Clarke

Expert team of Barristers and Solicitors with years of experience in providing advice and representation in Road Transport Law.

Please find some of our recent cases below.

Filter by Category


Successful Appeal Against Civil Penalties for Clandestine Entrants - September 2020

Simon Clarke acted for the Appellant in this court appeal against Civil Penalties for clandestine entrants. Our client, a Belgian haulier, was penalised following the discovery of clandestine entrants in a trailer delivered by him to Zeebrugge Port. The Secretary of State imposed the penalties even though the trailer had […]

Adblue Emulator Found, Poor Regulatory History, Licence Allowed to Continue After Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry. - September 2020

This Operator, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, was found to be operating a truck fitted with an Adblue emulator. When the DVSA probed further into the business they found that the operator had few systems in place to ensure regulatory compliance either in regard to drivers’ hours […]

Former Transport Manager Unable to Demonstrate Continuous and Effective Control Retains Full Repute - August 2020

  Barrister, Helen Newbold, represented this former transport manager when the Operator was called to a Public Inquiry for licence lending, not complying with undertakings on his operators’ licence, significant missing mileage, and a paucity of information in both driver and vehicle files. A DVSA investigation identified a significant amount […]

Transport Manager Survives Public Inquiry with Good Repute Undamaged - August 2020

The Transport Manager in this case, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, applied to be put on the licence of a coach company. The Director was called abroad on family matters and correspondence and the two communicated by text during his absence. Within 6 weeks of his appointment […]

Transport Manager Regains Good Repute on Application to the Traffic Commissioner - August 2020

This Transport Manager, represented by barrister Harry Bowyer, failed to turn up to his Public Inquiry as he had not notified his new address to the Office of the Traffic Commissioner and did not receive the call in letter. At the Public Inquiry he lost his good repute and was […]

Using an Operator’s Licence with Intent to Deceive – Prosecution Discontinued. - August 2020

Transport solicitor, Laura Newton, represented an Operator who had been accused of using an Operator’s Licence with Intent to Deceive. The Operator’s case was that although he accepted using a vehicle specified on another’s Operator’s Licence, this was purely a mistake in that he did not understand that the discs […]

The Wheel on the Bus Didn’t go Round and Round – It Came Off! Driver Escapes with Written Warning. - August 2020

The PSV driver was represented by Millicent Dooher, barrister, at the Driver Conduct Hearing after the wheel had come off the double decker school bus the driver was driving. Plainly in cases such as these some of the blame lay with others but the driver’s walkround is the last line […]

4-Week Suspension for LGV Driver Who Received 8 Fixed Penalty Notices from the DVSA - August 2020

Millicent Dooher represented the driver at the Driver Conduct Hearing after the driver had received 8 Fixed Penalty Notices from the DVSA. The Traffic Commissioner was persuaded that the driver had made drastic improvements from the time the penalties were issued, and as such reduced the suspension length to 4-weeks. […]

Bridge Strike with Hook Loader Operator receives Formal Warning in Virtual Preliminary Hearing - August 2020

This operator was represented by barrister Helen Newbold in a virtual preliminary hearing to determine whether the operator should be called to a full Public Inquiry after one of their drivers hit a Network Rail bridge.  An incorrectly stowed hook loader struck the bridge causing significant damage resulting in a […]

Bridge Strike with Excavator Driver Avoids 6 Month Disqualification - August 2020

Helen Newbold, barrister, represented this driver who was called to a Driver Conduct hearing after striking a road bridge with the hydraulic arm of an 18-tonne excavator.  With severe damage to the bridge and a trunk road closure of several hours, the driver was facing a sanction against his professional […]

Ask a Question

Let us know how we can help. Just provide a brief outline of your query.







    Free Consultation Motoring Law