Recent Cases | Smith Bowyer Clarke

Expert team of Barristers and Solicitors with years of experience in providing advice and representation in Road Transport Law.

Please find some of our recent cases below.

Filter by Category


DVSA Appeal Board Finds that DVSA Investigation into MOT Tester not Conducted Fairly - January 2022

We were instructed to act on behalf of an MOT Tester on appeal from a DVSA decision imposing a 5 year Cessation from testing. Representing the Tester on appeal, Solicitor Laura Newton challenged the DVSA Examiners in relation to their conduct. The Appeal Board agreed that the investigation had not […]

Good Repute In Question – Licence Granted at Public Inquiry with Conditions - January 2022

Our Operator client was called to Public Inquiry before the Traffic Commissioner in relation to an application for an Operator’s Licence. There was a recent history for the Company of Operating an unfit vehicle without a Licence which had called into question the repute of the Operator. Laura Newton was […]

MOT Authorised Examiner Escapes with Warning - January 2022

Our MOT Authorised Examiner client instructed Laura Newton when presented with a contemplated decision from DVSA relating to improper recording of an MOT when a vehicle was not present. Under the MOT Guide, the starting point for this is the imposition of 500 points and a 5 year cessation. In […]

£12,000 of Civil Penalties cancelled - January 2022

This European Haulier instructed SBC following penalties being imposed after the discovery of a number of clandestine entrants within one of their vehicles. These penalties were appealed at the County Court by barrister Millicent Dooher, where the Judge cancelled the penalties in full and awarded full costs to the Appellants.

Civil Penalties Reduced by More than 50% Upon Financial Grounds Only - January 2022

Millicent Dooher, barrister, submitted a Notice of Objection on behalf of this haulier and driver following large penalties being imposed after clandestine entrants were discovered within a vehicle trailer. These clients objected to the penalty on the level only, after accepting that they did not have in place a proper […]

Operator Operating HGVs with no Operator’s Licence Since 2019 – Licence Granted as Applied for - January 2022

The operator in this case, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, was operating HGVs from 2019 until he became aware that he needed an operator’s licence. The reality of the situation was that with a very few tweaks he could have fitted himself within a couple of the […]

Operator is Granted New Licence at Traffic Commissioner’s Despite Previous History of Non Compliance - December 2021

Barrister Helen Newbold represented this operator who had made an application for a new licence 3 years after the incorporation and commencement of his new company. Having held a sole trader licence for 20 years this operator was unable to show that he had any maintenance records for his vehicle, […]

Application for Operator’s Licence Granted as Applied for at Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - December 2021

The Applicant in this case, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, had their application called in to Public Inquiry. The Traffic Commissioner was concerned about a previous application made by a different company that the applicant director was also a director of. The previous application was rejected as […]

Application for Licence Called into Public Inquiry by Traffic Commissioner over Concerns about Applicant’s Licensing History – Granted as Applied for. - December 2021

This applicant, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, was called into Public Inquiry as a result of their previous licensing history which involved previous applications for licences which were granted but no vehicles being run on them. After hearing from the applicant the Traffic Commissioner granted the application […]

Operator is Granted New Licence Following History of Non Compliance on the Old. - December 2021

Barrister Helen Newbold represented this operator who had made an application for a new licence 3 years after the incorporation and commencement of his new company. Having held a sole trader licence for 20 years this operator was unable to show that he had proper and sufficient maintenance records for […]

Ask a Question

Let us know how we can help. Just provide a brief outline of your query.







    Free Consultation Motoring Law