Please find some of our recent cases below.
Filter by Category
- Bus and Coach
- Bus, Coach and PSV
- Challenging Penalties
- Civil Penalties for Clandestine Entrants
- County Court
- Criminal Defence
- Driver Conduct Hearings
- Driving Instructor
- Impounded Vehicles Returned
- MOT/DVSA
- PSV
- Public Inquiries
- Taxi/Private Hire Appeal
- Upper Tribunal
Bridge Striking Driver Avoids Revocation at Driver Conduct Hearing - February 2025
This driver, represented by barrister Harry Bowyer, appeared at a driver conduct hearing for striking a bridge to the extent that his load was displaced on the road and trains were slowed pending investigation. The starting point for bridge strikes in the Senior Traffic Commissioner’s Statutory Guidance is revocation of […]
Catering Firm Keeps Licence after Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - February 2025
This Operator, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, suffered badly during the Covid 19 pandemic and standards slipped badly. After an unsatisfactory DVSA investigation they were called into Public Inquiry. They instructed a competent transport consultant to fix their systems and the Traffic Commissioner dealt with them by […]
Success Appeal Against the Traffic Commissioner - February 2025
We were instructed by an Operator who had received a letter from the Traffic Commissioner revoking their Operator’s Licence. There had been a number of issues with the Operating Centre and DVSA co-operation, which the Operator was seeking to address. Laura Newton made an initial application with an Appeal to […]
SBC Response to “Contemplated Decision Letter” Proposing 500 Points for an MOT Authorised Examiner Reduces Outcome to a Warning and 100 Points! - February 2025
An MOT Authorised Examiner had been investigated and subject to DVSA disciplinary procedures due to a vehicle examiner discovering that there had been a period of time where MOTs had been undertaken without the required roller brake equipment, due to a technical fault awaiting repair. The MOT Guide allows for […]
Death of Transport Manager Leads to Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - January 2025
This operator, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, suffered the death of their transport manager. The death was unexpected and the transport manager was in continuous and effective control until shortly before he died. The operator had a new CPC holder in place in relatively short order and […]
Card Pulling Driver Committed to Crown Court Following Tachograph Offences Escapes with a Fine - February 2025
This driver, represented by Millicent Dooher, barrister, was sent to the Crown Court to be sentenced for 4 false record tachograph offences. Where these offences are dealt with in the Magistrates’ Court, these attract a fine only. Once they are referred to the Crown Court, the maximum sentence for each […]
£240,000 of clandestine entrant civil penalties reduced to just £15,160.00 and full costs - February 2025
Millicent Dooher represented this European haulier throughout their objection and appeal of the civil penalties. The haulier had a vehicle stopped with 20 clandestine entrants concealed in the vehicle. The penalties initially imposed totalled £240,000.00. By the end of the appeal, the penalty was reduced by over 93% to just […]
50% reduction and full costs awarded to European Haulier at clandestine entrant civil penalty appeal hearing - February 2025
This European haulier was represented at their appeal hearing before the County Court following the discovery of 1 clandestine entrant. The appeal was lodged on the basis that the Company had fully complied with the relevant regulations (and ought to get a 50% reduction) and that the Company qualified for […]
Border Force accept Company compliance for clandestine entrant civil penalty, reducing the penalties by 50% and contributing to appeal costs - February 2025
This European haulier, represented by Millicent Dooher, lodged an appeal to the County Court on the basis that they were entitled to a 50% reduction on their penalty for full compliance with the Regulations. The penalties had already been reduced on a means basis at the Notice of Objection stage. […]
Clandestine Entrant Civil Penalty Pre-Court Settlement Reduced Penalties by Over £75,000.00 - February 2025
Millicent Dooher, barrister, represented this European haulier following the imposition of penalties for the carriage of clandestine entrants. The haulier was facing £99,000.00 of penalties following the discovery of 9 clandestine entrants in one of their vehicles. The Company was deemed to have fully complied with the Regulations but had […]


