Recent Cases | Smith Bowyer Clarke

Expert team of Barristers and Solicitors with years of experience in providing advice and representation in Road Transport Law.

Please find some of our recent cases below.

Filter by Category


£30,000 of Clandestine Entrants Civil Penalties Cancelled - November 2019

Lisa Lyden-Cowen submitted written submissions against the issue of civil penalties for immigrants for this Romanian client, which caused the penalties to be cancelled completely. Yet another example of how well constructed and presented arguments can succeed in having these, sometimes huge, penalties cancelled.

£20,000 of Low Emission Zone Penalties Cancelled on Appeal - November 2019

Our European client, represented by Simon Clarke, had been hit with Low Emission Zone penalties over a 6-month period last year. Simon represented the client before the London Tribunal and obtained the cancellation of every single penalty.  Transport For London did not oppose the appeal.

Three Month Old Licence Called in to Public Inquiry Owing to Card Pulling Drivers - November 2019

This holder of a restricted licence, represented at Public Inquiry by Harry Bowyer, was called in three months into his operating history. He had outsourced his tachograph analysis to a company that failed to provide him with any infringement reports. This was unfortunate as his drivers began to pull their […]

Transport Manager Woes Lead to Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - November 2019

The Operator in this matter was worried about his Transport Manager’s ability. He, very sensibly, commissioned an audit which showed that the Transport Manager, who was operating under Grandfather rights, was far from competent. The replacement turned out to be not much better and was sacked. During this unhappy period […]

Licence Retained After “Compliance Fell off a Cliff.” - October 2019

This Operator was called into his second Public Inquiry in 5 years. He was represented by Harry Bowyer at both Public Inquiries. After surviving the first Public inquiry the Operator, who had a restricted licence, was under the care of a first rate transport consultant who oversaw the transport team […]

Both Licences Saved After Two Companies Operate for a Year without a Transport Manager After Death of Transport Manager - October 2019

In this case two brothers, each of whom had an operator’s licence and each represented by Harry Bowyer, continued to operate after their father, who was also their transport manager, died. Neither notified the Office of the Traffic Commissioner of the death of the Transport Manager and neither applied for […]

Operator with a 49% Overload Survives Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry - October 2019

The operator in this case, represented at Public Inquiry by Harry Bowyer, operated both HGVs and a fleet of vans. One of the vans was stopped en route to Scotland groaning under a load that was 49% in excess of what it should have been – a most serious infringement! […]

Operator with Poor Maintenance Record and Poor Document Retention Keeps Licence at Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry. - October 2019

The Operator in this matter, represented by Barrister Harry Bowyer, brought themselves to the attention of the Office of the Traffic Commissioner by a flurry of prohibitions including an impressive “S” marked prohibition for a completely bald tyre with the cords exposed. The resulting Traffic Examiner’s Operator Report (TEOR – […]

Operator Operating Under Exemption Successfully Applies for Operator’s Licence - October 2019

This operator, represented at Public Inquiry by Harry Bowyer, was operating HGVs under the “plant” exemption. They were scrupulous in abiding by the regulations that would have applied had they been operating under a licence. They wanted to bring themselves within the operator licensing regime in order that they could […]

Licence Allowed to Continue as Licence Lending Suspicions Not Proven - September 2019

Harry Bowyer, Road Transport Barrister, represented this operator who was suspected of lending his licence to another operator. The operator was able to show that throughout the relevant period he had been maintaining the vehicle and downloading the vehicle unit and relevant driver cards. The Traffic Commissioner stated that he […]

Ask a Question

Let us know how we can help. Just provide a brief outline of your query.







    Free Consultation Motoring Law