Recent Cases | Smith Bowyer Clarke

Expert team of Barristers and Solicitors with years of experience in providing advice and representation in Road Transport Law.

Please find some of our recent cases below.

Filter by Category


Vehicle Restored to Operator Without Penalty - May 2021

This client’s vehicle had been seized following the discovery of 350,000 cigarettes with an estimated value of approximately £150,000.00. Following written representations made by Millicent Dooher, for the restoration of this vehicle, Border Force have accepted the request for restoration with no fee. Usually for a first detection the fee […]

No Requirement for Public Inquiry Following Successful Preliminary Hearing - May 2021

This Company was represented by barrister, Millicent Dooher, at their preliminary hearing before the Traffic Commissioner. The Company had been called in following a bridge strike and a subsequently inadequate DVSA review. The Traffic Commissioner was content, following submissions that no Public Inquiry was necessary, and no further action needed […]

Successful Appeal of Civil Penalty Reduces Level of Penalty. - May 2021

Barrister, Millicent Dooher, represented this client and three drivers at a civil penalty appeal hearing before the County Court following penalties being imposed of almost £16,000.00. Millicent was able to successfully convince the Court that the level of the penalty was too high, even where the Court had determined that […]

Transport Manager Keeps Good Repute after Traffic Commissioner’s Public Inquiry. - May 2021

This Transport Manager, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, made the usual mistake of remaining on the licence of an uncooperative operator for far longer than he should have done. At Public Inquiry we were able to demonstrate repeated messages from the Transport Manager to the Operator requesting […]

SBC Represent Ten Drivers at Driver Conduct Hearing – All Dealt with Below Recommended Starting Point. - May 2021

SBC were approached to represent ten drivers from the same company who were to be dealt with at a Driver Conduct Hearing for assorted tachograph breaches including card pulling. Barristers Helen Newbold and Millicent Dooher represented the drivers, many of whom were looking at long suspensions or revocation of their […]

Driving Instructor Remains on Register After DVSA Interview. - May 2021

Solicitor Laura Newton represented an Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) who was being investigated relating to alleged breaches of the Code of Conduct. The breaches alleged included mobile phone use whilst working, poor quality of lessons and a sexual relationship with a pupil driver, which was admitted. The matter was investigated […]

Operator on Interim Licence is Granted Full Licence after Using Unauthorised Operating Centre - May 2021

This operator, represented at Public Inquiry by barrister Harry Bowyer, was called into Public Inquiry for their application for an Operator’s Licence to be considered. The operator had had their previous licence revoked for regulatory failings and but had escaped disqualification. They had applied for a new licence and had […]

Operator Only Loses Margin After Glut of PG9’s and Maintenance Failings - May 2021

This operator, represented by Barrister Helen Newbold, was called to Public Inquiry after two DVSA Maintenance investigations showed recurring maintenance failings and a high number of prohibition notices on both tractor units and trailers. The operator demonstrated that despite being “old school” he was keen to comply and had already […]

Operator Granted Interim Licence in Terms Applied for Despite Maintenance Failings. - May 2021

This operator, represented by barrister Harry Bowyer, was called into Public Inquiry for the second time in three years. He had two licences in two separate traffic  areas and wanted to consolidate them into one licence by operating from one operating centre in one traffic area. A desk based assessment […]

Unauthorised Operating Centre and Systemic Failings for Company Result in a 14 day  Curtailment of Fleet and Loss of Margin. - May 2021

Barrister Helen Newbold represented this operator who had been using an unauthorised operating centre for several years. After being called into Public Inquiry for this, and a number of non-compliance issues in respect of other licence undertakings, his maintenance regime also became under scrutiny. A catalogue of basic failings was […]

Ask a Question

Let us know how we can help. Just provide a brief outline of your query.







    Free Consultation Motoring Law